made it clear that such attitudes do not reflect the priorities
of the general public. Whatever faults they might perceive in
social programs, Americans do not want to see them dismantled.
Although many are concerned about the dependency of the poor,
people at all levels have benefited from some government-supported
social protections like Social Security, Medicare, and mortgage
interest deductions. And it has remained clear that private charity
and voluntarism, as important as they are, cannot fully meet the
social needs of our citizens. Government participation is
essential; we must learn from past experience how governments can
respond more efficiently to the nation's social welfare needs.
Some lessons of
that experience are obvious: Americans ought not to have to choose
between the public and private sectors as avenues for dealing with
problems of social welfare. Both are intimately linked; they should
complement and support each other. Nor can we rely on economic
growth alone to guarantee social welfare. A healthy economy, while
essential, will not of itself generate the human investments and
mutual caring that are necessary for a strong, just society. And
while America has grown properly skeptical of programs that foster
dependency, it has also learned that it is futile to ask people to
take greater personal responsibility for their lives unless they
have a real chance to escape from material conditions that foster
insecurity and despair.
Years of
experiment, success, and failure have also yielded a wealth of
practical knowledge. We know, for example, what must be done to
bring healthy babies into the world. We know that high-quality
programs for preschool children pay dividends in later years. We
know how to combine health, education, and family support services
to help disadvantaged schoolchildren. We know that employment
programs, though no panacea, can offer cost-effective improvements
in the lives of many, including mothers on welfare.
Visions
and Realities
An obvious
conclusion arises from this accumulated knowledge. The best welfare
policy offers individuals both economic opportunity and social
protection, and it does so in a way that minimizes the waste of
taxpayers' resources. Self-reliance ought to be encouraged, but it
will be most effective within the context of a supportive social
framework. Work is fundamental to an enlightened social welfare
program, but people often need assistance in preparing for work, as
well as some basic social support while they are working. At the
same time, a government that offers help in the form of social
programs must resist being exploited by people who will