achieving cost savings and in passing such savings along to
consumers. Indeed, some analysts have accused the construction
industry of refusing to use cost-saving technologies in order to
keep the price of housing high. Over the years, much
effort—both public and private—has been invested in
finding a solution to the high cost of housing production. Success
has been more marginal than hoped, but the effort has helped to
reveal the complexity of the housing cost problem and the extent to
which its components are intertwined.
The key factors
that contribute to rising production costs are land and financing.
Land is by far the more important of the two. Other
components—labor, materials, and profit—have remained
steady, or have declined. Table 2 shows the relative importance of
various production components over time.
TABLE 2
Costs of Development (%)
(Single-Family Housing)
| Cost Components |
1949 |
1984 |
| Land |
11 |
22 |
| Materials |
36 |
31 |
| Labor |
33 |
16 |
| Financing |
5 |
11 |
| Profit/Overhead |
15 |
20 |
|
100 |
100 |
| Source: National
Association of Homebuilders. |
In reviewing
Table 2, it is easy to recognize that even a dramatic reduction in
any one factor will make only a small difference in the overall
cost of a unit. For instance, assume that the price of land were
reduced by 50 percent for an average newly built home (priced at
$99,200 in 1985). This would show up as an 11.5 percent reduction
in the total cost of a unit, or a reduction in final cost of
$11,000. This savings would lower the minimum annual income needed
to purchase the home by only $4,000. Further, a 50 percent
reduction in the cost of financing would reduce the final cost of
the home by 6 percent, and lower the income needed to purchase it
by only $2,000.
Multifamily
construction offers some important cost savings largely because of
the lower land allocation per unit. In 1980 HUD conducted a study
to compare production factors among several of its multifamily
programs. The report provides comprehensive cost information on
thousands of units in twelve HUD-sponsored rental housing programs.
Of special