View all Archives -
Environment and Development »
Forestry for Sustainable Rural Development
Revisions in
monitoring procedures are another critical means of
institutionalizing program flexibility and innovation. Instead of
producing reports on success in meeting pre-set targets, new
monitoring systems attempt to establish channels of communication
that continually expand agency knowledge of local conditions and
program developments. In this way, project monitoring becomes a
part of the forest department's learning process. NGO members of
working groups assisting state or national forest departments often
conduct the research and analyses of field-level experience. The
information generated then provides a basis for further policy and
structural change. For example, the state governments of both
Haryana and West Bengal have radically revised their original joint
forest management resolutions based on monitoring and experience
gained with JFM.
In Haryana,
for example, the state working group constantly updates the base of
information about developments in JFM. Substantial contributions
are made by the NGO participants who have been documenting the
experience in pilot projects and conducting ecological studies. In
light of the new knowledge generated, appropriate changes have been
made by the Haryana government to smooth the working of the locally
based Hill Resource Management Society (HRMS). Some of the changes
are summarized below.
| From |
To |
| Providing technical and
managerial inputs |
Building technical and
managerial competence in the local people |
| Rigid allocation norms for
forest areas to be protected by the forest protection
committee |
Forest areas defined on
the basis of natural features and after consultation with
neighboring village representatives and intra-village
groups |
| Each household is a member
of the forest protection committee |
Every adult in the village
is a member, ensuring equal representation by gender |
| An umbrella policy
regarding sharing benefits between the Forest Department and the
HRMS |
Share percentages
differentiated by commodity |
| A sharing arrangement of
fixed percentages between the Forest Department and HRMS |
As an incentive for
protection, 75 percent of the yield above the base-line production
goes to the HRMS |
| Only the Haryana Forest
Department has the right to fine |
HRMS given the right to
levy fines and introduce regulations |