organizations. The deficiencies of many oil pollution studies,
including those at Santa Barbara, are regrettable. But one must
conclude from studies around the world that the ecological effects
depend greatly on the nature of the oil spilled. On the other hand,
it does not seem reasonable to conclude, as have some oil company
spokesmen and consultants (), that the West Falmouth spill was
atypical in effect due to the type of oil, confinement of the
spill, and weather conditions. Studies of the West Falmouth spill
suggest that the same kinds of effects, even if not of equivalent
magnitude, could be experienced following a spill of any type of
oil, even crude oil ().
The geography
of the spill is of obvious importance. We have already speculated
on spills in polar and tropical regions and in estuaries. Also the
biotic nature of habitats varies greatly within temperate zones;
for example, the east coast of the United States is geologically
and ecologically quite different from the west coast, and the
Louisiana coastal environment is quite unlike that of Maine.
The time of
the year the spill occurs may also be critical. Had the Santa
Barbara spill happened earlier, nursing pups of sea lions and
elephant seals may have succumbed after ingesting oil coating their
mothers teats, and sea bird populations would have been greater.
Also a spill could endanger the success of a seasonal reproductive
period.
Meteorological and oceanographic conditions
influence the effects of an oil spill. Floating oil responds
primarily to winds and currents and may be blown inshore or
offshore. Floating oil from the Santa Barbara spill met
sediment-laden plumes of low salinity runoff waters generated by
atypically heavy rains (). Oil mixed with the sediments, sank, and
settled on the bottom rather than on the shore. Similarly, at West
Falmouth onshore winds churning oil with sediment deposited oil on
the bottom, killing many bottom animals ().
An improper
clean-up strategy can worsen the effect of oil pollution. The
Torrey Canyon spill taught us the lesson of rampant misuse
of toxic dispersants. The sinking of Torrey Canyon oil off
Brittany shifted its impact from the intertidal to the subtidal
benthic environment, where more areas are affected and the oil may
persist.
SHORTCOMINGS OF RESEARCH ON OIL
POLLUTION
Although the
literature on effects of oil in the marine environment is of
considerable bulk, on balance ecologists have failed to come to
grips with the biological effects of oil. Certainly, this may also
be said of other seaborne pollutants we know very little about. Yet
we know even less about oil than about heavy metals and pesticides,
for example. Although there is undoubtedly a complex array of
cultural, economic, and political explanations for this
generally